Skip to content

Earthing systems TT, TN, IT

The earthing system decides what happens when a live wire touches a machine frame: what trips, how fast, and whether production stops. Pick a system to see its wiring, then check your installation.

TransformerMMachineL1L2L3NRnRaFaultTT
Maximum Ra allowed (UL / IΔn)
1666.7 Ω
Fault current Id
4.6 A
Touch voltage on the frame
184 V

✓ The earth electrode is good enough: the RCD trips before the touch voltage becomes dangerous.

Indicative result: always verify against the standards and the installation method on site.

Publicité

Formula

TTRa≤UL/IΔn
TNId=0.8 U0/(ρ L (1/Sph+1/SPE))≥Im

Good to know

  • Three-phase network: U0 is the phase-to-earth voltage, 230 V on a 230/400 V network and 400 V on 400/690 V. Conventional method: 80 % of the voltage remains at the origin of the circuit during the fault.
  • Magnetic threshold taken at the top of the curve (B = 5 In, C = 10 In, D = 20 In), on the safe side.
  • Measure the earth with an earth tester or a loop tester, not with a multimeter.

What is it, simply?

Two things in an installation can be connected to earth: the transformer neutral and the exposed metal parts (machine and panel frames). How they are connected is the earthing system.

Two letters describe it. 1st letter, the neutral: T = earthed, I = isolated (or earthed through a high impedance). 2nd letter, the frames: T = connected to a local earth, N = connected to the neutral. In TN, a 3rd letter gives the conductor: C = neutral and protective combined (PEN), S = separate (N and PE).

TT: earthed neutral, earthed frames

The neutral is earthed at the transformer, and each building has its own earth electrode for the frames. If a wire touches a frame, the fault current flows through the ground between the two electrodes: only a few amperes, too little to trip a circuit breaker.

So the RCD protects: it detects the leakage and trips. Rule: Ra × IΔn ≤ 50 V. With a 30 mA RCD the earth can be up to 1,666 Ω; with 500 mA it must stay under 100 Ω.

Use: generally the system of customers supplied at low voltage by the public network (homes, shops, small workshops). Pros: simple, low fault current (little damage). Limits: everything relies on the RCD and a good earth; the surge protector must sit upstream of the RCD.

TN-S, TN-C, TN-C-S: frames connected to the neutral

The frames are connected to the transformer neutral point by a protective conductor. A fault becomes a real phase-to-frame short circuit: the current is high and the breaker trips magnetically, without an RCD.

Condition: the cable must not be too long, otherwise its impedance limits the current and the breaker does not trip in time. That is what the “maximum protected length” check verifies. Beyond it, increase the section, use a B curve or add an RCD.

TN-C: a single PEN conductor for neutral and protection. Cheap, but not allowed below 10 mm² copper or for flexible cables, and no RCD is possible. Neutral currents flow in the frames and disturb electronics.

TN-S: N and PE separate all the way. The best choice for automation: clean frames, RCDs possible, less noise on PLCs and analogue measurements.

TN-C-S: PEN at the start, then split into N and PE in a panel. After the split they are never joined again. Use: plants with their own MV/LV substation.

IT: isolated neutral, production keeps running

The neutral is not earthed (or only through a high impedance). On the first fault the current is almost zero: nothing trips and the machine keeps running. An insulation monitoring device (IMD) raises the alarm.

The fault must then be found and fixed quickly: if a 2nd fault appears on another phase it is a short circuit and the protection trips, as in TN but with maximum lengths about half as long.

Use: continuous processes where a stop is costly or dangerous (furnaces, chemicals, cement plants, mines, operating theatres). It needs a trained maintenance team and insulation monitoring.

Problems seen in plants

RCD tripping for no reason: drive EMC filters create permanent leakage. Use RCDs suited to drives (type B or F depending on the equipment) and 300 mA on motor feeders where the rules allow it.

Jumping 4-20 mA or PT100 readings: often a TN-C system where neutral current flows through frames and shields. Moving to TN-S and earthing the shield at one end only (PLC side) solves many cases.

Degraded earth: rods corrode and the soil dries out in summer. Measure the earth at least once a year and after any works.

Frequently asked questions

+What earth resistance is needed in TT?

Ra × IΔn ≤ 50 V (25 V in wet locations). With a 30 mA RCD: up to 1,666 Ω; 300 mA: 166 Ω; 500 mA: 100 Ω. In practice aim for a low, stable earth, measured every year.

+Why is TN-C a problem for PLCs?

Neutral and protection share one conductor: neutral and harmonic currents flow through frames and shields, disturbing analogue inputs and communications. TN-S avoids this.

+In IT, must the first fault be tripped?

No: the first fault is signalled by the insulation monitor and production continues. But it must be found and repaired quickly, because a second fault causes a short circuit and a stop.